Site logo
Vacation RentalsDestinationsProperty ManagementContact Us
Vacation RentalsDestinationsProperty ManagementContact Us
About Us
About Us

All About Casago

Blog
Blog

Explore Our Blogs

Franchise with Us
Franchise with Us

Become a Franchise

FAQs
FAQs

Most Common Questions

  1. USA >
  2. New York >
  3. Penn Yan

Benton Farmhouse

Classic country retreat with a game room, bar, expansive outdoor space, & grill
Classic country retreat with a game room, bar, expansive outdoor space, & grill
Classic country retreat with a game room, bar, expansive outdoor space, & grill

House in Penn Yan, New York

Guests
16 Guests
Bedrooms
6 Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3 Bathrooms

Locally Owned & Operated

Casago Silva Vacations

Casago Silva Vacations

Casago Franchise Owner

Locally Owned & Operated
Rating4.50

What our guests are saying...

AI-generated from guest reviews for this property

Benton Farmhouse is praised as a spacious and welcoming home that comfortably suits large groups, with plenty of room to gather and spread out. Guests found it clean, well kept, warm, cozy, and comfortable, with roomy bedrooms, comfy beds, and ample bathrooms that supported group stays with ease. The farmhouse is appreciated for its beautiful character, vintage charm, rich sense of history, and interesting family mementos that create a memorable atmosphere. Its location was valued for being convenient to nearby attractions and events while still offering privacy. Guests also enjoyed the large yard and outdoor space for games and relaxing, along with indoor recreation like ping pong, chess, and a book room that added to the experience. Overall, Benton Farmhouse is described as a fun, distinctive, and highly enjoyable place that guests would gladly return to.

Overview

We will send you all necessary pre-arrival and check-in information after booking. This can include guest instructions, notices, and other helpful information. What We Love A restful pastoral retreat from the city, the Benton Farmhouse is the perfect place for large families and friend groups to reconnect and reflect with the people who mean the most to you. Spacious, and boasting old-world charm, this beautifully restored historic home radiates an abundance of warmth. Conveniently located on Route 14A in the middle of the Wine region of the Finger Lakes, this home is perfectly located to tour and explore the area. It can also serve as a relaxing base for wedding parties using multiple local wedding venues. Enjoy cozy movie viewings from the comfort of the spacious living room's soft seating. Engage in some playful competition over a game of chess under the glow of the library's lamps, or any of the many games for all ages in the living room or the huge recreation room. When hunger arises, head for the well-equipped kitchen and play chef amongst the full suite of appliances and ample meal prep space. Serving your dishes will be a breeze at the expansive, formal dining table. After eating, enjoy a night in while playing Ping-Pong in the wood-lined recreation room/TV-watching area. Mix your game nights with delicious concoctions prepared at the recreation room bar. With six large bedrooms to choose from, rest assured that no one's comfort will go unattended to. Each of the rooms offers soft linens, vintage decor pieces and furniture, and cool air - thanks to the home's partial air-conditioning. Additional interior perks include a private washer/dryer, a high chair, internet access, and office space with a desk and printer in the quiet library. After a couple of front door steps, the lower level of the house has a bathroom and bed available. Outside, enjoy the country breeze while grilling or sitting in front of the dancing flames in the fire pit. Enormous lawns encourage spirited games of corn hole and badminton, while the large driveway can be set up for pickleball, all of which are supplied. When exploring the surrounding area, be sure to check out the numerous regional wineries, excellent local restaurants (we can suggest our favorites), charming Penn Yan (“Penn' for the Pennsylvanians and “Yan” for the Yankees who settled the area in the early 1800s), the scenic Finger Lakes, Keuka Lake Outlet trail, Keuka Lake State Park, Finger Lakes Rail Riders (just around the corner), Canandaigua Country Club, or further up the road, Hunt Hollow Ski Club. Don't be surprised if you encounter horse-drawn buggies sharing local roads on your way to Windmill Market just south of Penn Yan, which hosts dozens of shops, produce, and food to enjoy. House Rules Check-in time: 4:00 PM Check-out time: 10:00 AM All guests shall abide by the good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 PM to 8:00 AM No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises.

You must be 21 years or older to rent this property.

Amenities

Air conditioning
Air conditioning
Gas grill
Gas grill
Board games
Board games
Dishwasher
Dishwasher
Washer/dryer
Washer/dryer
Heating
Heating
High chair
High chair
Internet
Internet
Iron
Iron
Snowbird-friendly
Snowbird-friendly
Microwave
Microwave
Patio
Patio
Ping-pong table
Ping-pong table
Stove
Stove
TV
TV
Meeting and events allowed
Meeting and events allowed

Sleeping Arrangements

Bedroom 1

sleeps 3

Beds
1 king bed
Beds
1 twin bed

Bedroom 2

sleeps 4

Beds
1 queen bed
Beds
1 double bed

Bedroom 3

sleeps 2

Beds
1 queen bed

Bedroom 4

sleeps 2

Beds
1 queen bed

Bedroom 5

sleeps 2

Beds
1 queen bed

Bedroom 6

sleeps 2

Beds
1 queen bed

Common Space 1

sleeps 2

Beds
1 double bed

Location

Penn Yan, New York, Home

(Exact address will be provided after booking)

Location

Rating

4.5
22 reviews
5 Star
68%
4 Star
14%
3 Star
18%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
0%
search
Victoria M2026-07-27

This is a wonderful property with plenty of room to spread out both inside and out. The house was immaculate and well located for the wedding we were attending 15 minutes down the road at Crispin Hill. Would 100% stay here again.

Gregory R2026-07-22

The home was beautiful. The history of the home was interesting. We enjoyed looking at the book room and delving into history. Fascinating!

Carol M2026-07-06

Our family group of 11 was very comfortable here as this house has lots of room to spread out and a well-stocked kitchen with plenty of dishes. The backyard was great for playing frisbee and roasting s-mores.

Sabrina U2026-06-01

We hosted a board game retreat for some friends and the house very much suited our needs. The older furniture at times was not the most comfortable since we were doing a lot of sitting while playing games, but overall we loved the space and would consider going back in the future. At one point there was a leak in one of the windows (it rained all Memorial Day weekend), but the property managers were very prompt in coming out to fix the issue.

Hilary H2026-05-19

We had a lovely weekend stay to celebrate a Hobart and William Smith graduate. We had 13 people around the table for dinner in the well equipped dining room, and 9 sleeping over in the comfy beds. The home has three full baths which made it fairly easy for everyone to get enough bathroom time. We didn't take advantage of the ping pong table in the additional family room, but it looked like a really nice one. The home is right on a busy road, but there is a fence along the front of the property that gives plenty of privacy, and the road was fairly quiet at night.

Joanne M2026-05-03

Cleanliness

$400
avg / night
Rating4.50

You won't be charged yet

Sparkling and spotless stays

Arrive at a completely cleaned and inspected home.

Professionally Managed

Our properties are professionally managed to maintain high standards.

Transparent Pricing

No hidden fees or surprise charges. What you see is what you pay.

Our Destinations
View all
Site logoVeteran Owner

Quick Links

  • Newsroom
  • Videos
  • Executive Team
  • Casago Careers
  • Promotions/Discounts
  • Apps

CONTACT US

  • 850 NW 13th Ave.
  • Suite 400
  • Portland, OR 97209

NEED MORE HELP?

  • Contact us now

©2026 Casago. All rights reserved

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service
FacebookInstagramYouTubeLinkedIn