Lamplighter Inn - 114 Angel Fish Reef

I liked the cleanliness and privacy

There were a lot of negative comments on this listing but limited availability for dogs in this small quaint seaside town. We took a risk and rented for our trip and I cannot understand how anyone would have anything negative to say. The location is great. The rooms were Huge and clean! The beds were comfortable and check in was easy. There is a wonderful Mexican restaurant located right beside it that served great food and we ordered 20 mins before closing. The room was plenty big for three adults. The ice machine outside was working. And when I couldn’t find my email for the check in code I texted the number and they responded promptly. This is not a new property but is lovingly cared for. The design inside the angelfish room was beautiful. The shower was the hottest I have had in any upscale hotel in a long time! We would love to stay again❤️

Very comfortable beds. Excellent communication for everything we needed to know.

When I arrived I noticed that the large front window could not be locked. I reported it immediately, stating that it was a safety hazard. I did not receive a response so I went to Ace and purchased a dowel rod and had it cut to size. When I left two nights later the lock had still not been secured. This is a huge lack of concern for the safety of the room’s occupants.

Available & Comfortably Also reasonable price

Office closed when we arrived - had to make a phone call to get the code for the room. Then had to wait two hrs to receive the code via email. Room was not the special for all the trouble.