New Buffalo Vacation Rentals

1-24 of 59 rentals
Livywood Cottage

Livywood Cottage

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.88
Persons
6Persons
Bedrooms
2Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$151/night
The Tree House

The Tree House

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.68
Persons
6Persons
Bedrooms
2Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$237/night
Happy Thoughts Cottage

Happy Thoughts Cottage

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.72
Persons
4Persons
Bedrooms
2Bedrooms
Bathrooms
1Bathrooms
$245/night
The Oasis at Forest Beach

The Oasis at Forest Beach

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.50
Persons
14Persons
Bedrooms
5Bedrooms
Bathrooms
4Bathrooms
$1,104/night
Charlotte Chateau

Charlotte Chateau

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.29
Persons
14Persons
Bedrooms
5Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$491/night
Creekside Retreat Pool House

Creekside Retreat Pool House

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.50
Persons
15Persons
Bedrooms
6Bedrooms
Bathrooms
5Bathrooms
$740/night
Merchant Street Pool Retreat with a Year-Round Hot Tub.

Merchant Street Pool Retreat with a Year-Round Hot Tub.

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.54
Persons
8Persons
Bedrooms
3Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$377/night
Hydrangea House

Hydrangea House

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.53
Persons
6Persons
Bedrooms
3Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$536/night
Downtown Hideaway

Downtown Hideaway

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.72
Persons
8Persons
Bedrooms
4Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$446/night
Nothin Dune

Nothin Dune

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.70
Persons
10Persons
Bedrooms
5Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$2,225/night
The Pelton House

The Pelton House

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating3.86
Persons
14Persons
Bedrooms
5Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$603/night
Eagles Nest

Eagles Nest

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.25
Persons
12Persons
Bedrooms
6Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$673/night
Surf's Up

Surf's Up

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.55
Persons
8Persons
Bedrooms
4Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$442/night
Leisure On The Lake

Leisure On The Lake

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.67
Persons
16Persons
Bedrooms
6Bedrooms
Bathrooms
5Bathrooms
$1,139/night
Sunset Vista

Sunset Vista

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.78
Persons
8Persons
Bedrooms
3Bedrooms
Bathrooms
4Bathrooms
$348/night
Anchors Away

Anchors Away

House in New Buffalo, MI

Rating4.25
Persons
8Persons
Bedrooms
2Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$222/night
The Sunset House

The Sunset House

House in Grand Beach, MI

Rating4.52
Persons
10Persons
Bedrooms
3Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$144/night
Grand Getaway

Grand Getaway

House in Grand Beach, MI

Rating4.50
Persons
11Persons
Bedrooms
5Bedrooms
Bathrooms
4Bathrooms
$651/night
Mac's Bluff

Mac's Bluff

House in Grand Beach, MI

Rating4.48
Persons
14Persons
Bedrooms
4Bedrooms
Bathrooms
4Bathrooms
$604/night
Lake Michigan Charmer

Lake Michigan Charmer

House in Union Pier, MI

Rating4.14
Persons
5Persons
Bedrooms
2Bedrooms
Bathrooms
1Bathrooms
$117/night
Harbor Country Family Lodge

Harbor Country Family Lodge

House in Union Pier, MI

Rating4.79
Persons
16Persons
Bedrooms
4Bedrooms
Bathrooms
5Bathrooms
$787/night
The Bright Side

The Bright Side

House in Union Pier, MI

Rating4.85
Persons
9Persons
Bedrooms
3Bedrooms
Bathrooms
2Bathrooms
$329/night
Azure Forest Pool House

Azure Forest Pool House

House in Union Pier, MI

Rating4.36
Persons
10Persons
Bedrooms
4Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$485/night
The Point on Williams Court

The Point on Williams Court

House in Union Pier, MI

Rating4.33
Persons
14Persons
Bedrooms
5Bedrooms
Bathrooms
3Bathrooms
$586/night

© 2026 Casago LLC